With the holidays right around the corner, I’ve already started a list of must-read books and must-see movies. Kicking back to enjoy a book or movie is always a top priority for me when it comes to free time. You just can’t beat some good ol’ R & R! This time last year, I gave into the
Twilight madness and contributed to the first movie’s success (er, four times). The loss of all social skills quickly followed as I read the whole series over the holiday break (envisioning Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart all the while). Seeing the movie first really helped, as I had no idea how much the story had been cut down. Had I read the books first—well, I probably wouldn’t have been a fan of the big screen adaptation. Good thing the cast is ‘kind of beautiful.’
So I thought I’d ask the BookPros team to share their favorite books that have been made into movies—a double whammy!
ErinI'd have to say my favorite movie based on a book is the A&E version of
Pride and Prejudice (you know, the Colin Firth one). It's one of the most faithful adaptations of a Jane Austen novel I've ever seen (and I think I've seen them all). The Andrew Davies screenplay is terrific, and nearly every role was perfectly cast. While no movie could do full justice to the near perfection of Austen's masterpiece, this one comes pretty close. I watch it a couple times a year, which is high praise, considering it's five hours long!
PeggyI'm really excited to watch
The Lovely Bones, which I read for one of my book clubs in anticipation of the
movie. We read it a couple months ago, and the movie just came out. I generally expect movie renditions to be disappointing. It's hard for a movie to match the vision in my head, and I realize a lot of cutting has to be done so the movie doesn't last ten hours. However, Peter Jackson directed this one, so my expectations are definitely higher than usual. I read
Lord of the Rings before the movies came out and was not disappointed by the movie at all. He did an amazing job. But Tolkien gave him some great stuff to work with.
That's definitely the exception to the rule for me, though. I've found that it's best for me to leave at least a month between when I read the book and when I watch the movie. Otherwise I get overly upset when tiny details (or sometimes bigger plot twists) are left out or changed. If it's been a while, I've probably read a handful of other books in the meantime and forget those things.
KatieMy favorite movies that were adapted from books are, in no particular order,
Bridget Jones's Diary (based on the Helen Fielding book, which I liked a lot),
A Room with a View (based on the E. M. Forster book, which I loved), and
Clueless (admittedly a very loose adaptation of
Emma, but still good). A more recent book-turned-movie that I really enjoyed was
Fantastic Mr. Fox. On the flip side, I loved Maurice Sendak's
Where the Wild Things Are. The movie? Not so much.
CaitlinWell, if you were to ask my mom, the librarian, the book is always better than the movie! For me, a lot of the time, there's a gap of a year or two between when I read a book and see a movie, so I often can't remember if the book is better than the movie or vice versa.
Here are some of my top picks:
The Time Traveler's Wife: Loved both the book and the movie.
Julie and Julia: Enjoyed the book and thought the movie was entertaining.
Gone Baby Gone: Haven't read the book, but thought the movie was very well done.
The Blind Side: Just saw the movie and am now inspired to read the book.
CodyThe type of material I enjoy reading is different than the type of movies that I watch, so I don't think I've ever read a book and then watched the movie based on it. I enjoy watching action/adventure and science fiction movies, but only really read nonfiction material. Even if I wanted to, I would probably try to avoid reading a book before I watched the movie based on it. It seems that every person who does this is always disappointed with the movie, since the movie will inevitably change and leave out some things. I think it's better to read the book after you watch the movie; that way, it's like getting the backstory to the movie after having watched it.
Here are some silver screen titles to keep an eye out for:Beautiful Creatures by Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl (
learn more)
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg Larsson (
learn more)